Thu 21 Aug 2008
Guidelines for Newbies
Posted by ray under Psychology
Guidelines for Novice Traders
Cross ref : http://awanginvest.com/?p=680
MASTER TRADERS LEAGUE
August 21, 2008 – 5:00 pm
With the seminar coming up this weekend that I organized for my mentor at the Singapore Management University, I would like to touch on how novice traders could take a pro-active approach to learning to trade well. The course to be conducted by Ray Barros, who is in the class of Master Traders, would highlight the road to take and to form good habits of trading.
I merely wish to give some guidelines seeing how choppy the markets have been lately. August is also the month when families go away.
It may be best to sit on one’s hands and do no trade. Or one could devote more time to learning how to trade well.
There are many would-be traders turning to the markets for wealth and security. Yet, in spite of the need to win, many fail to achieve enduring financial success.
The recurrent question is “Why?”
Before I answer this one word question, I would like to reveal what I believe is the greatest obstacle to trading success by would -be traders.
At some recent presentations in which I assisted my mentor, I was saddened by some expressing some unrealistic views to me. They all are eager to learn to trade but they only attend freebies, thinking that a couple of hours of presentations would suffice to teach them all the techniques for a good trade.
Also many want to trade for a living but they have not shown any commitment to master the markets. One major move is to invest in knowing how to trade . As with any profession, like a doctor, one must first invest money , time and efforts to reach competency in whatever we profess to be. There is no short-cut or instant success. This is contrary to what we are bombarded with , ads giving the impression that trading is easy to make quick and high returns. You have to put more than money on the line, to incorporate trading into your life and do whatever it takes to hone your trading skills to the point where you become competent.
Goethe the philosopher observed , which many novice traders would be wise to heed: “Until one is committed, there is hesitancy, the chance to draw back.”
In his book, The Mentally Tough Online Trader, Robert Koppel observes, “Top performing traders are committed to overcome any hardship or roadblock to achieve their goals.”
You must commit money. You cannot expect to make a living from a $1,500 trading account. Until you have a nest-egg you can afford to lose, you should not even think of trading. If you are under-capitalized, you need to get an extra job to build up the capital you need. You also need to invest time and energy – a huge commitment on your part.
It is impossible to digest the full range of trading knowledge over-night, even if you were a genius. Learning about the markets and developing an intuitive feel as to how they behave requires time and practice. It can take many years before you can trade the markets profitably. Some can do it within 3 years with consistent profits, many will take up to 10 years to be really good. But to the trader who is fully committed, these are minor setbacks. Once you make the commitment to master the markets, you are on the way to success with good habits.
On the psychological level, once you have invested in a trading course, you must learn to let go and move on when you start to trade. When you trade with the proper mental edge, you flow with the markets. You do not worry about how much you may lose. You are energized and focused entirely on the markets. Of course, It is hard to focus once you have a string of losses.
Professor Jennifer Lerner, at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government, studies how emotions impact judgments, such as the financial decisions traders make daily. Her recent study showed how a combination of focusing on oneself and feeling sad can produce biased perceptions of the value of a commodity. These results highlight the impact of focusing on the experience of feeling sad rather than maintaining an objective state of mind. When trading the markets, it’s vital to stay objective and focused on the trade. If you feel sad, disappointed, or depressed and mull over these feelings, you may overestimate the value of a stock or commodity.
Winning traders stay objective. They take setbacks in stride. They objectively survey the markets. They view setbacks and losses as merely a symptom of an inevitable change in market conditions, and take an active problem solving approach rather than a passive approach marked by depression.
Traders who become consumed with setbacks and unpleasant emotions dwell on internal reasons for a setback - their inadequacy as a trader. They start focusing inward and may hold on to losing trades rather than cut their losses short and look for a new high probability setup. Winning traders do not look inward at all. Instead, they look at the market action and make an active problem solving approach to recover from the setback.
Many novice traders blame themselves for their setbacks. Again, “ Why”? Lacking inexperience, they tend to focus on their lack of trading ability. They stop looking for solutions and give up too quickly. If only they just stay focused and continue to search for solutions, they will increase their chances of finding a solution to move forward rather than stumble.
Last but not least, you must not forget about risk controls. Also, do not trade beyond your skill level. The only way you are going to hone your trading skills and become a seasoned trader is to practise by making trade after trade across various market conditions. The more focused you can trade and the more responsive you are, the more likely you will be one of the few who can be called winning traders.
Bonne chance!
ANA aka IDKIT
Ag Moderator




























August 21st, 2008 at 10:49 am
Those Who Can’t Trade Teach - is what we hear bandied about …WRONG!
Here is what John Forman has to say:
Think about it. If no one who ever could do taught, then the bulk of our educational system would be gone. Think of all the college professors who are experts in their fields who both do and teach. If no one who ever could do shared what they do, no one would ever learn the doing!
……………………….Basically, this person is telling me that I must be a poor trader since I’m in the education business. Of course they know next to nothing about me, so they really have no basis for drawing any conclusion one way or the other. This sort of thinking is indicative of a failure to consider all the reasons why someone might get into education in the first place.
Yes, there are certainly those out hocking systems and whatnot who are insincere and unscrupulous. That’s the reality of things. Of course trading is hardly alone in that. There are always going to be con artists in every venue where they see the potential for profit.
Ana aka Idkit
August 21st, 2008 at 12:54 pm
Hi Ana, I agree. The quote “Those Who Can’t Trade Teach …” cannot be blindly applied and there are those like Ray that really enjoy teaching while they remain very successful traders.
While there are others that can’t teach or trade yet teach !
Why do successful traders train ?
My guess as well is that training allows traders an opportunity to meet and socialise with like minded people and they enjoy it.
but good point Ana
Tom
August 21st, 2008 at 1:45 pm
Thank you, Tom, for your points of view.
John Forman has his pet project to donate to.
Our mentor enjoys teaching as well as his way to share/return his knowledge/experience to the trading society.
Being karmic, I have my own pet projects for essentially the same reason, to return a little back to society when we can.
Ana aka Idkit
August 22nd, 2008 at 1:12 pm
Ideas to Finish Off the Market Week - Dr Brett
http://traderfeed.blogspot.com/2008/08/ideas-to-finish-off-market-week.html
* Tough Trading - Quantifiable Edges looks at the challenges of trading a choppy market environment; see the commentary also from Afraid to Trade.
* No Decoupling in an Information Age - Excellent perspective from Paul McCulley, contributing to The Big Picture.
* Good Reading - The difficulties of running a hedge fund, sobering views on real estate, and other good updates from Trader Mike. Check out excellent readings from Abnormal Returns, including what $SOX performance means for the market and views on hedge fund performance.
* Questioning the Doubters - John Forman challenges the idea that those who can’t trade teach.
* For Those Starting Out - Ana Wang and the Market Success blog offer perspectives for new traders.
* Preparation - Before the N.Y. stock market open, Kirk posts his overview of the day and premarket movers; Mike posts his watchlist.
* Two Excellent Readings - A sobering view from David Rosenberg via John Mauldin. See also Stratfor’s take on the current geopolitical equation following Russia’s action in Georgia.
* Fun List - Top 100 undiscovered websites, from PC Mag.
* Getting Smaller - The eminis were supposed to address small traders; now we have microlot trading.
.
Posted by Brett Steenbarger, Ph.D. at 6:35 AM
1 comments:
IDkit aka Ana said…
Bon voyage, Brett.
Will catch up when you touch down on the Lion City ……….
Selamat datang!
ANA aka IDKIT