Wed 20 Aug 2008
How to profit from the Carry Trade - Idkit
Posted by ray under Miscellaneous
Profiting from the Carry Trade
Cross ref from http://awanginvest.com/?m=200808
August 20, 2008 – 12:00 am
Monthly chart of NZDJPY -inflows of carry trades
The carry of an asset is the return obtained from holding it , if positive, or the cost of holding it , if negative.
Commodities are usually negative carry assets because of storage costs but they can be positive carry assets as the market is willing to pay a premium for availability.
This can also refer to a trade where one can earn the spread between borrowing a low carry asset and lending a high carry one.
Carry trades must not be confused with arbitrages. Pure arbitrages make money no matter what. Carry trades make only only if nothing changes.
For example, traditional income stream from commercial banks is to borrow cheap at low overnight rate which they pay depositors and lend expensive at the long term rate.
This works in an upward yield curve but when the curve becomes inverted, it loses money. The floating of short term rates when Paul Volcker was chairman of the FED was a case in point.
According to a popular anecdote, traditional commercial banking can be characterized as a ‘3-6-3′ business - borrow at 3%, lend at 6%, earning 3% spread and be on the golf course by 3pm.
The carry trade from the point of view of traders refers to currency carry trade . Investors borrow low-yielding and lend high-yielding currencies. This tends to correlate with global financial and exchange rate stability and retracts during global liquidity shortages.
The risk is that foreign exchange rates may change so that investors would have to pay back more expensive currency with less valuable currency. Carry trades weaken the target currency because investors sell the borrowed sum and convert it to other currencies.
For example, the yen currency pairs have become the speculators’ pair du jour.
Since the late 1980s, the Bank of Japan had set Japanese interest rates at very low levels making it profitable to borrow the yen to fund activities in other currencies such as subprime lending in the US, emerging markets and resource rich countries.
Let us look at NZD/JPY, one of the favoured pairs now. Here a carry trader would borrow the yen @ 0.5% and then convert it into NZD. After the conversion, the trader would then buy a Kiwi bond for the corresponding amount, earning 8%. Therefore the investor makes a 7.5% return on the interest alone after taking into account the 0.5% that is paid on the yen funds.
The investor is also hoping that the price will appreciate to make more on the transaction. For 2007, traders were able to benefit from a 7.5% return as well as from a currency appreciation of 20.6% since the beginning of the year on the NZD/BPY transactions.
ANA aka IDKIT
Ag Moderator




























August 20th, 2008 at 2:25 am
Hi Ana, This is an interesting article. I have long been fascinated by this and arbitrage. Hope to read more sometime. Thankyou Baz
August 20th, 2008 at 3:40 am
Baz, happy my simple basic posts also help advance traders like you.
Whenever I hold the fort for our mentor, I take the opportunity to offer something different , less mind-boggling than his , for sure, that all readers may find useful be it as a revision for most readers here.
I have to call him this morning as his intermediary as his net was down in the hotel and managed to put him on to the States for his web interview.
How amazing the net has become for instantaneous resolutions to connection problems, too.
His interviewer wrote to thank me and to say the interview went off superbly; hope I will be given permission for the recording to share in due course.
As I write, Ray is visiting his mom again in hospital; she is frail but high in spirit to see her children, as expected. Thanks for asking.
Ana
Ag Moderator
August 20th, 2008 at 4:01 am
Hi Ana,
Thank you for one of the clearest explanations of the Carry Trade that I’ve read. The background info was great.
Can you provide any follow up articles on the specifics of “borrowing in Yen, then buying say a NZ bond” for the interest arbitrage. Eg; Could this be done through instruments available through IB TWS? (I’ve always wondered how to secure the Yen loan against the NZ bond to provide security on the loan - or is this not required?)
My understanding is that any foreign currency fluctuations can then be hedged for those who want to just earn the rate spread and make the interest only (forfeiting any possibly capital gain but also avoiding any risk of capital loss).
Essentially it’s just an interest rate arbitrage play but I’ve not seen any specifics on how best to implement one.
Cheers. Paul H.
August 20th, 2008 at 6:28 am
Paul
Thank you; nice to be of some help on the Carry Trade.
While I am still a newbie, let me try and put it this way on say NZDJPY in 2007 when it attracted such transactions.
1. You can borrow JPY100K at 0.5% pa
2. You then convert the Yen to NZD
3. You then buy Kiwi bonds yielding 8% pa
4. Your returns will be 8 - 0.5 = 7.5% pa
Additionally, you hope the NZD will appreciate to reap more profits.
This series of transactions cannot be made on a trading platform, I think.
Hope Ray can comment or add to what I understand about Carry Trade, Paul.
Ana
Ag Moderator
August 20th, 2008 at 10:00 am
Thanks Ana, much appreciated. Yes, it would be great if Ray could write something on the practical side of carry trades.
I’ve heard about it a lot yet never seen how it’s actually implemented by traders.
Regards
Paul H.
August 20th, 2008 at 10:52 am
Paul, here is some elaboration on the risks of a Carry Trade by Tom: cross ref
http://awanginvest.com/?p=675
Nice in theory but for the retail trader your broker generally only pays interest on short positions by the amount the quote currency rate exceeds libor/euribor/…
In addition we take the risk of an adverse change in currency value (JPY gains …) but may offset that in options but again a cost to us.
So 2 sides - the theory and the practical execution to consider
By Tom on Aug 20, 2008
August 20th, 2008 at 11:01 am
Thanks, Stranger from the land of the Leprechauns.
I think even if one does not use Options, one can still do the Carry Trade quite profitably as I would , by using cash, no leverage, bearing in mind a ’stop loss’ and a high probability trade.
ANA
Ag Moderator
August 20th, 2008 at 3:50 pm
The GBPJPY has been the classic carry trade for several years from the 2001 to 2006, which saw a movement from 190 to 250 in end 2006. There’s an article that estimated holding 1 full lot ($100,000) for the whole duration would have yielded $40,000 in profits.
Having said that, recent weakness in the economies of Australia, NZ and Europe in general, with the threat of rate cuts, has seen the carry trade unwind in the past few weeks.
November 18th, 2008 at 4:13 am
very interesting post hope to see some additional comments here…
November 18th, 2008 at 4:20 am
Hi Tatiana
That was a post by Ana Wang at Idkit. She steps into the breach whenever I am unable to maintain my blog.
Ana you’re welcome to post a follow-up blog anytime.